口頭答覆 · 2025-03-03 · 屆國會 14
公職人員使用DeepSeek限制
議員質詢政府是否考慮限制公職人員使用DeepSeek，類似他國對政府裝置的禁令。政府回應稱有政策框架評估技術適用性，強調安全與創新並重，但未直接回應DeepSeek限制問題。質詢方追問政府自研AI工具Pair是否依賴國外商業平臺，政府未詳細說明，表示可私下跟進。核心爭議在於政府對具體商業AI產品的態度及資料安全透明度。
關鍵要點
- • 政府有技術使用政策
- • 未明確限制DeepSeek
- • Pair AI工具細節未公開
通過政策框架保障安全創新
要求明確DeepSeek限制措施
持續評估AI安全與合規
“The Government has policies, frameworks and processes to guide the use of technology in the public sector.”
參與人員 (3)
- Gerald Giam Yean Song
- Janil Puthucheary
- Senior Minister of State for Digital Development and Information
完整譯文（中文）
Hansard 原始記錄 · 2026-05-02
4號議員嚴彥松先生向數字發展與信息部長提出問題：(a) 政府是否考慮對公務員使用DeepSeek實施限制，類似於其他一些國家對政府裝置使用該工具的禁令；(b) 如果沒有，是什麼因素使新加坡採取了不同的做法；(c) 政府如何確定哪些人工智慧模型被認為足夠安全，適合公共部門使用？
數字發展與資訊高階國務部長（代數字發展與信息部長）賈尼爾·普圖切裡博士答覆：先生，政府擁有指導公共部門使用技術的政策、框架和流程，包括人工智慧（AI）等新興技術。這使我們能夠根據效能、安全性和韌性等因素，評估技術在不同使用場景中的適用性。這樣公共部門機構能夠有效利用創新技術，同時確保政府運作和職能的安全與可靠。
我們定期審查和更新政策，以應對不斷變化的技術環境和安全考量。
議長：嚴議員。
嚴彥松議員（阿裕尼）：先生，感謝高階國務部長的答覆。我注意到他沒有直接回應我關於DeepSeek的問題。如果他能更直接地回答，我將不勝感激。
其次，我有一些補充問題。我瞭解到政府開發了Pair，這是一套利用大型語言模型的人工智慧工具，供公共服務內部使用。高階國務部長能否澄清，Pair主要使用本地部署的開源模型，還是連線到像ChatGPT和DeepSeek這樣的商業人工智慧平臺，這些平臺會在國外伺服器上處理資料？
賈尼爾·普圖切裡博士：先生，感謝嚴議員的提問。政府通常不對具體商業產品發表評論。我們建議企業根據產品自身的優劣及使用風險進行評估，包括其是否符合相關法律。
Pair確實訪問大型語言模型，但並非僅訪問單一模型。關於Pair的具體細節，我手頭沒有。如果嚴議員對技術細節感興趣，我很樂意私下與他跟進，或者他也可以提交後續的議會質詢。
英文原文
SPRS Hansard · Fetched: 2026-05-02
4 Mr Gerald Giam Yean Song asked the Minister for Digital Development and Information (a) whether the Government is considering restrictions on the use of DeepSeek by public officers, similar to bans imposed by some other countries on its use on Government devices; (b) if not, what factors justify a different approach in Singapore; and (c) how does the Government determine which AI models are deemed secure enough for public sector use.
The Senior Minister of State for Digital Development and Information (Dr Janil Puthucheary) (for Minister for Digital Development and Information) : Sir, the Government has policies, frameworks and processes to guide the use of technology in the public sector, including emerging technologies like artificial intelligence (AI). This allows us to evaluate the suitability of technologies for different use cases, based on factors such as performance, security and resilience. This enables public sector agencies to use innovative technologies effectively while ensuring the security and reliability of government operations and functions.
We regularly review and update our policies to address the evolving technological landscape and security considerations.
Mr Speaker : Mr Giam.
Mr Gerald Giam Yean Song (Aljunied) : Sir, I thank the Senior Minister of State for his reply. I note that he did not address my question regarding DeepSeek. I would appreciate if he could address that more directly.
Secondly, I some supplementary questions for him. I understand that the Government has developed Pair, which is a suite of AI tools that utilise large language models for internal use within the Public Service. Could the Senior Minister of State clarify if Pair is primarily using locally deployed open source models or does it connect to commercial AI platforms, like ChatGPT and DeepSeek that process data on foreign servers?
Dr Janil Puthucheary : Sir, I thank Mr Giam for his questions. The Government does not generally comment on specific commercial products. We advise companies to evaluate products on their own merits and the risks of use, including their compliance with relevant laws.
Pair does indeed access large language models, but it does not access only one. The specific details of Pair, I do not have them on hand. If Mr Giam is interested in the technical details, I would be happy to follow up with him offline or he can file a subsequent Parliamentary Question.